Message Creation Date was at 12-APR-1999 17:08:00
NOTE: COMMENTS ARE TO BE SENT TO MELINDA HASKINS.
ALSO NOTE THAT EOP STAFF WILL NOT RECEIVE A FAX COpy OF THE ATTACHED
MATERIALS.
---------------------- Forwarded by Robert J. Pellicci/OMB/EOP on 04/12/99
04:55 PM ---------------------------
LRM ID: MDH50
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Monday, April 12, 1999
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO: Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
FROM: Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Reference
OMB CONTACT: Melinda D. Haskins
PHONE: (202)395-3923 FAX: (202)395-6148
SUBJECT: HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES Testimony on Welfare Reform
Implementation
DEADLINE: 1 p,m. Tuesday, April 13, 1999
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on
the above subject before advising on its relationship to the program of
the
President. Please advise us if this item will affect direct spending or
receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions of Title XIII of
the
Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: The attached HHS (Golden) testimony will be delivered at a April
14th
hearing before the Senate Committee on Indian Affairs on welfare reform
implementation.
THIS DEADLINE IS FIRM. IF WE DO NOT HEAR FROM YOU BY THE COMMENT
DEADLINE, WE
WILL ASSUME THAT YOU HAVE NO OBJECTION.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
7-AGRICULTURE - Marvin Shapiro (LRMs & EBs) - (202) 720-1516
59-INTERIOR - Jane Lyder - (202) 208-4371
61-JUSTICE - Dennis Burke - (202) 514-2141
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
110-Social Security Administration - Judy Chesser - (202) 358-6030
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
EOP:
Elena Kagan
Barbara Chow
Cynthia A. Rice
Barry White
Jack A. Smalligan
Maureen H. Walsh
Anil Kakani
Michele Ahern
Andrea Kane
Eugenia Chough
J. Eric Gould
Richard B. Bavier
Lori Schack
Natasha F. Bilimoria
Peter Rundlet
Robert G. Damus
Jeffrey A. Farkas
Barry T. Clendenin
Mark E. Miller
James J. Jukes
Janet R. Forsgren
Brian S. Mason
Elizabeth Gore
Sandra Yamin
Crystal J. Roach
LRM ID: MDH50 SUBJECT: HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES Testimony on Welfare
Reform
Implementation
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for.views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment) ,
we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this response sheet.
If
the response is short and you prefer to call, please call the branch-wide
line
shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a message with a legislative
assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be connected to
voice
mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, .and the subject shown below.
TO: Melinda D. Haskins Phone: 395-3923 Fax: 395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
FROM: (Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the
above-captioned subject:
Concur
NO Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
HHS (GOLDEN) TESTIMONY FOLLOWS ---
The following attachments were included with this message:
TYPE FILE
NAME tribos.doc
================== END ATTACHMENT 1 ==================
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D41)MAIL49719261J.136 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FFS7S043821C0000010A0201000000020S000000FSCF000000020000S2AC971S3E74SFE3FF2CB4
B72D9DD93EE638DDE384DOS2BE6107439326COFBASS2AC971S60FOC9F7313B7F87E9ECBSASECDF
6F3SD4B2676E84942BE9SDAA23BB6E66BD4C3864C2EOSCB8SA343SBSlS03A0442A8F71SA2E8B29
6B1A9S086E2262DSB4FA38S0F79ESB413648B28FFFEOAA1EB2730SA63C6134686A9A6CS7A4EOAS
D149SD4DSC84S6D7968AB27BD04CF1A8ADDCA32F4612E2B99C67431A4BB66E87S2C1A9EBD081AD
D6B9SEC1S96CDF222249DC4A83C4A790S1FOEEF1CS819BC6SBSES702A497D2FOFS2C7A163D4EA6
30D13A77FDCCC3F3BF9CSC8738D66DF6BCF72S232C08816467AD6FF5BEBA1EF3Dl12AOOF02ED53
lCA8BF074DASE7B6E4BES40D23F1F2EDOE9690021B476E79400DA846CF71SF90DC930624776846
6240SA49AA27ASBS193868BA7994BA80B60CCF980BBA484928F486382AA3197FC3COAE3BADAE06
Automated Iteeords Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE: o 00:00:00.00
The following attachments were included with this message:
TYPE FILE
NAME tribos.doc
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Good morning Mr. Chairman and members of the Committee. I am pleased to be here
today to discuss welfare reform, especially as it relates to tribal families. The Personal
Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act ofl996 (PRWORA) focuses on
work and critical supports for work (in particular child care and child support). It offers
tribes a range of important new choices in designing welfare, child care and child support
programs that will provide the maximum opportunities to tribal families. We have
sought to work closely with tribes as they implement these provisions in the full spirit of
government-to-government relationships.
At the federal, state, tribal and community level, new relationships are being forged.
Early findings of research conducted by Dr. Eddie Brown with the Washington
University School of Social Work and funded by the Administration for Children and
Families indicate that "communication, coordination, and collaboration among tribes,
between tribes and states and tribes and the federal government has increased."
Governments are collaborating with businesses, community organizations, transportation
providers, the media and religious leaders to help move families to work. At the federal
level, we are focused on helping tribes, states and communities move families to work, be
1
Hex-Dump Conversion
accountable for results, and develop and share information about effective practices.
Together as partners, we must build upon these early efforts to find effective ways to
improve the lives of children and families.
Today, I would like to provide an overview of the changes made by welfare reform, child
support and child care as they affect tribes and discuss the work we are doing to ensure
that welfare reform is successful for tribes and tribal families. While it is too early in the
implementation of these programs to provide information on outcomes and results for
tribal families, I would also like to use this opportunity to share some promising activities
we are hearing about.
Statutory Changes
As I indicated, PRWORA made a number of significant changes that directly affect tribes
and tribal families.
2
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
First, under welfare reform the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)
program replaces the former Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) program
and provides States and tribes with unprecedented flexibility to design welfare programs
to meet the particular needs of families in moving to work and self-sufficiency. Tribal
governments, at their option, may receive direct federal funding to independently design,
administer, and operate the TANF program or may choose to allow States to continue
providing these services to tribal families.
In addition to the creation of T ANF under this reform legislation, the former Tribal
JOBS program was replaced with the Native Employment Works (NEW) program.
The NEW program provides funding for Tribes and inter-tribal consortia to design and
administer tribal work activities that meet the unique employment and training needs of
their populations while allowing states to provide all the other T ANF services.
States and tribes that administer their own T ANF or NEW programs have the flexibility
to design their programs, define who will be eligible, establish what benefits and services
will be available, and develop their own strategies for achieving program goals, including
3
Hex-Dump Conversion
how to help recipients become self-sufficient. Further, PRWORA provided tribes with
expanded child care funding and broader authority to administer the child support
program. Therefore, tribes can enter into new partnerships with states to ensure that
tribal families receive the support services necessary to become self-sufficient.
How Statutory Changes are Affecting Tribal Programs
TRIBAL ADMINISTERED TANF AND NEW PROGRAMS
The new law specifically allows tribes to administer the T ANF program and in such cases
federal T ANF funds are allocated directly to the tribe. While the law requires that tribes
meet certain goals in these programs, it also allows them to negotiate applicable work
participation rates with the Secretary, taking into account the limited resources and
employment opportunities available in the tribal community.
4
Hex-Dump Conversion
Since the President signed PRWORA in 1996, we have provided considerable assistance
to the tribes and have approved 19 tribal TANF programs. These TANF programs
involve 62 Indian Tribes and Alaska Native Villages, and operate in 12 states. The
programs are serving approximately 3,500 families, or over 13,500 individuals. There
are an additional seven plans pending which would involve an additional 78 tribes and
villages and affect over 35,000 more people.
Supported by HHS policy, all 12 states in which tribes are operating their own T ANF
program are providing some form of funding assistance to the tribes, similar to the
maintenance of effort dollars supporting State programs. Nine states are providing
matching funds (Oregon, Arizona, California, Wyoming, Washington, Alaska, Idaho,
Minnesota and Montana). The remaining three states are providing other resources such
as computers, staff training, and connection to their state reporting systems. In addition,
several states have out-stationed state employees to these tribal T ANF programs to assist
in eligibility assessments of TANF applicants for other state services.
5
Hex-Dump Conversion
Tribes are afforded even greater flexibility than states in designing their programs and like
states are making varied choices to meet their own unique circumstances. Time limits
on benefit receipt vary: 17 plans allow for 60 months of benefits, with the remaining
two providing 84 months. Under the work requirements, participation rates and the
number of hours of work required per week also vary from plan to plan. Four tribes
adopted th~ same participation rates the law requires of states (25 percent in the first year,
increasing to 50 percent by the fifth year for all families and 75 percent in the first year,
increasing to 90 percent in the third year for two-parent families). These tribes also
adopted the same minimum work requirements States are subject to meet. The
remaining tribes exercised their option to negotiate different rates of participation and
work hours and adopted a fairly wide range of rates.
Tribes have developed a variety of service strategies that respond to the unique
circumstances of each community. One tribe used casino revenues to build an
"Independent Life Skills Center," to house the Tribal TANF program. This center also
provides classrooms, a computer learning lab, a secure records facility, office space, and a
children's play area for use by TANF recipients. Another tribe, with joint funding
provided by the TANF program and the Bureau of Indian Mfairs, provides a "One-Stop"
and a "point of contact" service center for applicants requesting assistance and maintains a
6
Hex-Dump Conversion
toll free 24-hour voice mail service which can be utilized by TANF recipients and service
providers alike in serving recipients living in remote areas.
Under the NEW program, the statute restricts eligibility to tribes and Alaska Native
organizations that were operating JOBS programs in FY 1995. Currently, all 78
eligible tribal grantees are operating NEW programs. Total funding for these programs
is $7.6 million per year with a significant variation in the size of the individual grants
(ranging from just over $5,000 to $1.7 million).
STATE ADMINISTERED TANF PROGRAMS
In the remaining areas of the country, tribal families are served by state TANF programs.
In these areas, tribal communities and tribal members are subject to the same
responsibilities and eligible for the same opportunities that a state elects for its population
at large. As we learn more about the effect these service design choices are having on
tribal families, we certainly will share this information with the Committee. This type of
outcome data is particularly important in light of the unique challenges to self-sufficiency
7
Hex-Dump Conversion
faced by tribal families related to high unemployment and lack of transportation and child
care assistance.
As a start in gathering this critical data, in FY 1997, ACF approved a five-year research
and evaluation project entitled "Welfare to Work: Monitoring the Impact of Welfare
Reform on American Indian Families with Children." The overall purposes of this
longitudinal study are to monitor and document the implementation, and assess the
impact, of welfare reform on American Indian families and reservations in Arizona
resulting from the state and tribal responses to TANF. Extensive demographic,
contextual, socio-economic and case-level data will be compiled from a variety of sources,
including administrative records, tribal documents, interviews and site visits.
One of the preliminary findings of the study is that many tribes while interested in
self-administration of the program, are unsure about the best strategy to follow. They
are interested in learning form the experiences of other tribes in order to examine their
options and make informed choices.
8
Hex-Dump Conversion
On another front, a component of HHS's evaluation of the Department of Labor's
Welfare to Work Grant program will examine what activities and services tribes provide,
and how various tribal programs are coordinated at the localleve!.
CHILD SUPPORT ENFORCEMENT AND CHILD CARE
Child support enforcement is an essential part of welfare reform efforts. The child support
program locates non-custodial parents, establishes paternity, establishes and enforces
support orders, and collects child support payments from those who are legally obligated
to pay. Payment of child support can help a family to leave welfare or combined with
other income, reduce the need for single parent families and their children rely on welfare
in the first place.
Welfare reform enables tribes to operate their own child support enforcement programs
for the first time. PRWORA authorizes direct funding of tribal child support programs,
and with respect to tribes that do not seek this opportunity, includes improvements to
facilitate tribal-state agreements that provide for cooperative delivery of child support
9
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
services in Indian country. This added flexibility provides significant opportunities for
tribes and for Indian children and families: tribal governments can choose to plan and
implement child support programs that meet the unique needs of tribal communities and
improve the delivery of child support services in Indian country.
As I will discuss later in my testimony, we are reviewing the results of an extensive
consultation process which will lead to regulations that implement direct tribal child
support funding. In the meanwhile, although tribes are not yet operating programs
under the broad direct funding approach the law now allows, we are seeing some
promising results from early state-tribal cooperative agreements and tribal demonstration
grants.
_ Cooperative Agreements. Tribes such as the Navajo Nation and the
Sisseton-Wahpeton Sioux Tribe are entering cooperative agreements with their states,
enabling them to carry out tribal child support enforcement and receive funding and
other support through the states' programs. As a result of their cooperative
agreements with the State of New Mexico and Arizona, the Navajo Nation has seen a
big shift in child support collections. The Navajo Nation began child support
enforcement in New Mexico in 1994. Before then, there had been almost no child
support collection on the Navajo Reservation in New Mexico. In 1998, there was
$500,000 in child support collections under the tribe's child support program ill New
Mexico.
10
Hex-Dump Conversion
Tribal Demonstrations. Some tribes are designing child support programs with the
support of our planning and demonstration grants-"Section 1115" grants, Special
Improvement Project grants, and tribal planning grants. Currently, the Chickasaw
Nation, Colville Confederated Tribes, Puyallup Tribe, Lac du Flambeau Band of
Chippewa, Central Council of the Tlingit and Haida Indian Tribes, and the State of
Wisconsin and Menominee Tribe receive this discretionary grant funding. We are
learning from these projects, sharing information, and identifying issues and technical
assistance needs, to help ensure that tribes are able to operate successful child support
programs. Other tribes will benefit from the knowledge gained from these special
grant programs.
The third programmatic area I will focus on today is child care. Child care is' extremely
important to the well-being of our Nation's children and to their parents' ability to work
and maintain employment. and thus a vital supportive service to welfare reform efforts.
The Clinton Administration is dedicated to providing support and resources to ensure
healthy, safe, affordable child care settings that are so desperately needed to help parents
work and help children develop to their full potential and become ready for schoo!.
The Child Care and Development Block Grant (CCDBG) as amended by PRWORA,
assists low-income families and those transitioning off welfare to obtain child care so they
can work or attend training/education. PRWORA amended the CCDBG to bring
together, for the first time, four federal child care subsidy programs thereby allowing
11
Hex-Dump Conversion
states and tribes to design a comprehensive, integrated service delivery system to meet the
needs of low-income families.
Specifically, the law requires a one to two percent tribal set-aside of the aggregate funding
and allows tribes or tribal organizations to use program funds for construction or
renovation purposes as long as it will not result in a decrease in the level of child care
services.
The Secretary has allocated two percent of CCDBG funds for tribes, doubling the
amount of child care funds made available to the tribes since FY 1996. In FY 1999
tribes received $63 million, compared to the $28 million received in FY 1996. In FY
1999, 254 tribal grantees, representing approximately 500 Federally recognized Indian
Tribes and Alaska Native Villages, were awarded child care grants.
Tribes receive CCDBG funding either directly or through consortia arrangements.
According to preliminary 1997 data, 18,755 children were served by tribal childcare
grantees. The majority of these children have working parents (77 percent) or a
parent(s) in training or educational programs (19 percent). The remaining 4 percent
were in protective services. Their income levels vary with 63 percent at or below the
poverty level; 26 percent above poverty but below 150 percent of poverty; 8 percent
above 150 percent; and 3 percent above 200 percent of the poverty level.
12
Hex-Dump Conversion
I would point out that our efforts to increase the supply and availability of child care are
ongomg. The President has unveiled a comprehensive package of child care proposals
that includes significant increases in child care funding to help working families. Beyond
the tax credits and school-age child care funding in the Departments of Treasury and
Education, $10.5 billion in additional funding, over 5 years, is targeted for HHS child
care programs:
_ A five year $7.5 billion increase in the subsidy funding for child care which, when
combined with funds from welfare reform, will increase the number of children
receiving child care assistance by more than 1 million to a total of 2.4 million. The
tribal set-aside provided under law will ensure that this increase in funding serves to
benefit State and tribal child care programs alike.
_ An Early Learning Fund proposed at $3 billion over five years which will, for the
first time, specifically devote funding to communities to enhance the quality and
availability of care, with a focus on promoting school readiness for children through
age five.
I'd like to now turn to ACF's outreach, consultation, and technical assistance efforts to
work with tribes on these historic legislative changes
Outreach, Consultation, and Technical Assistance
13
Hex-Dump Conversion
In increasing the flexibility available to states and Tribes to design their own welfare
reform programs, PWRORA changed the Federal role from one of policy approval to
one that focuses on hands-on support through outreach, technical assistance, and the
dissemination of promising practices, as well as accountability, research, and evaluation.
In this concluding section, I would like to highlight what we have learned and
accomplished so far through consultation, outreach, and technical assistance with our
tribal partners and offer a few notes about the next steps that lie ahead.
Our goals, in keeping with this new role and with the gove'mment-to-govemment
relationship that is central to our work with tribes, are to consult broadly and to provide
information that can assist tribes in making the wide range of choices that they face
about the most effective ways to assist tribal members in becoming self-sufficient. To
help inform these decisions, we have been working with our tribal partners to provide
information about the statute, about policy choices, and about promising practices and
service delivery strategies. We have also worked to bring people together so that they
can share their own expertise, talk about problems and potential solutions, and then
develop strategies.
Outreach and Consultation.
14
Hex-Dump Conversion
In the development of the Tribal TANF Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM),
which was published on July 22,1998, we sought to undertake a broad consultation
strategy prior to drafting the proposed rules. To better inform our policy-making
efforts, we held dozens of conferences, consultations and meetings with representatives of
tribal, state and local governments, as well as soliciting input through a letter. An
extended comment period (through November 20, 1998) was provided on the proposed
rule at the request of commenters and as a result a considerable number of comments
were received from Tribes as well as the National Congress of American Indians. We
expect to publish the final rule this fall.
We continue to look for ways to strengthen and improve our consultation process. As
we work on development of regulations implementing the tribal child support program,
we further intensified our outreach efforts. Six consultations were held in 1998 to obtain
tribal input in developing the regulations in Alaska, Oregon, New Mexico, Minnesota,
Tennessee, and Washington, D.C. Each consultation included an overview of the
national CSE program, followed by tribal input on the tribal program and regulations.
In addition, we established a toll-free "800" number for comments and questions, and we
continue to consult with a resource group of interested and knowledgeable tribal
representatives. The input we have received is extremely valuable in helping to inform
our rulemaking efforts currently underway. We anticipate publication of the regulations
later this year.
15
Hex-Dump Conversion
We are committed to continuing and improving our consultation with tribes as welfare
reform evolves. In addition to our work within ACF, we are coordinating with the
broader tribal consultation strategy conducted by HHS, which has included listening
sessions nationwide as well as the scheduled appointment of a staff specialist in the
Office of the Secretary who will focus exclusively on tribal affairs.
Technical Assistance and Information Dissemination
In addition, we have been involved in providing technical assistance on a number of
fronts:
With respect to TANF, we have sponsored five Promising Practices National
Conferences and there was tribal representation at each. At the Phoenix conference,
a representative from the Center for American Indian Studies presented on the
"Reaching All Families" plenary panel as well as in the "Low Job Skills" workshop,
where tribal issues were discussed.
_ To build on this work, later in April, we are planning a 2-day workshop in Denver to
bring together Region VIII States, Tribes and Tribal Community Colleges. This
workshop is being designed to share information and best practices, strengthen the
16
Hex-Dump Conversion
Tribes' role in welfare reform, improve StatefTribal working relationships and increase
collaboration/networking between and among States, Tribes, and Tribal Community
Colleges.
_ The Administration for Native Americans within ACF has provided resources to
support technical assistance, as well. For example, ANA provided $1.2 million for
five grants to support efforts to develop and disseminate information on TANF,
including convening workshops and meetings with tribes to inform them about
TANF. Additional collaborative work among ACF programs is planned for the
future including comprehensive strategic planning conferences addressing social
services and economic development.
_ The Office of Child Support Enforcement issued briefing packages on the program
, and legislative changes to ensure that tribes could be fully engaged in consultation
meetings. The office also published and sent to all federally recognized tribes a
publication, "Strengthening the Circle: Child Support for Native American
Children." This publication describes the new opportunities for tribal CSE programs
and intergovernmental partnerships to meet the needs of tribal children and families.
17
Hex-Dump Conversion
In Phase II of its contract with the Native American Management Services, Inc.,
OCSE and NAMS are designing technical assistance plans for tribal child support
demonstration grantees. At an initial meeting with grantees held recently, tribal
participants identified problems and areas of need both specific to their tribes as well
as problems and areas of need shared by tribes in general. This information will be
used to develop technical assistance materials for tribes under cooperative agreements
with States and for tribes planning on administering their own child support
programs.
_ With respect to child care, in January 1998, we awarded a three-year contract to
establish and operate a Tribal Child Care Technical Assistance Center (TriTAC).
TriTAC assists tribal grantees in child care capacity building efforts through the
following major activities:a tribal child care home page; a toll-free information and
referral line; a software package to assist with program reporting; a newsletter; and an
annual tribal conference. A database of effective program strategies is also being
developed.
In conjunction with TriTAC, we are currently making plans to hold several training
sessions across the country for tribal child care grantees. The purpose of this special
training is to focus on one or two topic areas that have been identified by tribal
18
Hex-Dump Conversion
grantees, but not covered in depth at the National American Indian/Alaska Native
Child Care Conference, or at ACF regional meetings.
Again, we look forward to building on these technical assistance strategies, and we will
seek to be responsive as welfare reform evolves and the needs of tribes change over time.
CONCLUSION
Our goal in welfare reform is enabling families to move to work and to succeed at work
over the long haul. To accomplish this goal, we are eager to continue working with our
tribal and State partners to support their design of T ANF, child care, and child support
programs that will make the most difference to families. We look forward to building
on the extraordinary creativity and commitment that tribal leaders have already
demonstrated and on the positive first steps that we have already taken together to
share information, to consult, and to provide technical assistance and support in the spirit
of the government-to-government relationship with tribes.We know that in addition to
working internally to coordinate our efforts with the tribes, we also must work with our
19
Hex-Dump Conversion
other Federal partners and the Congress to address the serious economic and social
problems faced by tribes. We are committed to building on these early steps and
working together to see increasing numbers of tribal members improve their lives and
become self-sufficient.
Thank you Mr. Chairman, this concludes my prepared statement. I would be pleased to
respond to any questions you or members of the committee may have.
20
==================== ATTACHMENT 1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE: 0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
The following attachments were included with this message:
TYPE FILE
NAME tribos.doc
==================== ATTACHMENT 2 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE: 0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D41)MAIL49719261J.136 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FFS7S043821C0000010A0201000000020S000000FSCF000000020000S2AC971S3E74SFE3FF2CB4
B72D9DD93EE638DDE384DOS2BE6107439326COFBASS2AC971S60FOC9F7313B7F87E9ECBSASECDF
6F3SD4B2676E84942BE9SDAA23BB6E66BD4C3864C2EOSCB8SA343SBSlS03A0442A8F71SA2E8B29
6B1A9S086E2262DSB4FA38S0F79ESB413648B28FFFEOAA1EB2730SA63C6134686A9A6CS7A4EOAS
D149SD4DSC84S6D7968AB27BD04CF1A8ADDCA32F4612E2B99C67431A4BB66E87S2C1A9EBD081AD
D6B9SEC1S96CDF222249DC4A83C4A790S1FOEEF1CS819BC6SBSES702A497D2FOFS2C7A163D4EA6
30D13A77FDCCC3F3BF9CSC8738D66DF6BCF72S232C08816467AD6FF5BEBA1EF3Dl12AOOF02ED53
lCA8BF074DASE7B6E4BES40D23F1F2EDOE9690021B476E79400DA846CF71SF90DC930624776846
6240SA49AA27ASBS193868BA7994BA80B60CCF980BBA484928F486382AA3197FC3COAE3BADAE06
Automated Iteeords Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE: o 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
The following attachments were included with this message:
TYPE FILE
NAME tribos.doc
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Good morning Mr. Chairman and members of the Committee. I am pleased to be here
today to discuss welfare reform, especially as it relates to tribal families. The Personal
Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act ofl996 (PRWORA) focuses on
work and critical supports for work (in particular child care and child support). It offers
tribes a range of important new choices in designing welfare, child care and child support
programs that will provide the maximum opportunities to tribal families. We have
sought to work closely with tribes as they implement these provisions in the full spirit of
government-to-government relationships.
At the federal, state, tribal and community level, new relationships are being forged.
Early findings of research conducted by Dr. Eddie Brown with the Washington
University School of Social Work and funded by the Administration for Children and
Families indicate that "communication, coordination, and collaboration among tribes,
between tribes and states and tribes and the federal government has increased."
Governments are collaborating with businesses, community organizations, transportation
providers, the media and religious leaders to help move families to work. At the federal
level, we are focused on helping tribes, states and communities move families to work, be
1
Hex-Dump Conversion
accountable for results, and develop and share information about effective practices.
Together as partners, we must build upon these early efforts to find effective ways to
improve the lives of children and families.
Today, I would like to provide an overview of the changes made by welfare reform, child
support and child care as they affect tribes and discuss the work we are doing to ensure
that welfare reform is successful for tribes and tribal families. While it is too early in the
implementation of these programs to provide information on outcomes and results for
tribal families, I would also like to use this opportunity to share some promising activities
we are hearing about.
Statutory Changes
As I indicated, PRWORA made a number of significant changes that directly affect tribes
and tribal families.
2
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
First, under welfare reform the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)
program replaces the former Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) program
and provides States and tribes with unprecedented flexibility to design welfare programs
to meet the particular needs of families in moving to work and self-sufficiency. Tribal
governments, at their option, may receive direct federal funding to independently design,
administer, and operate the TANF program or may choose to allow States to continue
providing these services to tribal families.
In addition to the creation of T ANF under this reform legislation, the former Tribal
JOBS program was replaced with the Native Employment Works (NEW) program.
The NEW program provides funding for Tribes and inter-tribal consortia to design and
administer tribal work activities that meet the unique employment and training needs of
their populations while allowing states to provide all the other T ANF services.
States and tribes that administer their own T ANF or NEW programs have the flexibility
to design their programs, define who will be eligible, establish what benefits and services
will be available, and develop their own strategies for achieving program goals, including
3
Hex-Dump Conversion
how to help recipients become self-sufficient. Further, PRWORA provided tribes with
expanded child care funding and broader authority to administer the child support
program. Therefore, tribes can enter into new partnerships with states to ensure that
tribal families receive the support services necessary to become self-sufficient.
How Statutory Changes are Affecting Tribal Programs
TRIBAL ADMINISTERED TANF AND NEW PROGRAMS
The new law specifically allows tribes to administer the T ANF program and in such cases
federal T ANF funds are allocated directly to the tribe. While the law requires that tribes
meet certain goals in these programs, it also allows them to negotiate applicable work
participation rates with the Secretary, taking into account the limited resources and
employment opportunities available in the tribal community.
4
Hex-Dump Conversion
Since the President signed PRWORA in 1996, we have provided considerable assistance
to the tribes and have approved 19 tribal TANF programs. These TANF programs
involve 62 Indian Tribes and Alaska Native Villages, and operate in 12 states. The
programs are serving approximately 3,500 families, or over 13,500 individuals. There
are an additional seven plans pending which would involve an additional 78 tribes and
villages and affect over 35,000 more people.
Supported by HHS policy, all 12 states in which tribes are operating their own T ANF
program are providing some form of funding assistance to the tribes, similar to the
maintenance of effort dollars supporting State programs. Nine states are providing
matching funds (Oregon, Arizona, California, Wyoming, Washington, Alaska, Idaho,
Minnesota and Montana). The remaining three states are providing other resources such
as computers, staff training, and connection to their state reporting systems. In addition,
several states have out-stationed state employees to these tribal T ANF programs to assist
in eligibility assessments of TANF applicants for other state services.
5
Hex-Dump Conversion
Tribes are afforded even greater flexibility than states in designing their programs and like
states are making varied choices to meet their own unique circumstances. Time limits
on benefit receipt vary: 17 plans allow for 60 months of benefits, with the remaining
two providing 84 months. Under the work requirements, participation rates and the
number of hours of work required per week also vary from plan to plan. Four tribes
adopted th~ same participation rates the law requires of states (25 percent in the first year,
increasing to 50 percent by the fifth year for all families and 75 percent in the first year,
increasing to 90 percent in the third year for two-parent families). These tribes also
adopted the same minimum work requirements States are subject to meet. The
remaining tribes exercised their option to negotiate different rates of participation and
work hours and adopted a fairly wide range of rates.
Tribes have developed a variety of service strategies that respond to the unique
circumstances of each community. One tribe used casino revenues to build an
"Independent Life Skills Center," to house the Tribal TANF program. This center also
provides classrooms, a computer learning lab, a secure records facility, office space, and a
children's play area for use by TANF recipients. Another tribe, with joint funding
provided by the TANF program and the Bureau of Indian Mfairs, provides a "One-Stop"
and a "point of contact" service center for applicants requesting assistance and maintains a
6
Hex-Dump Conversion
toll free 24-hour voice mail service which can be utilized by TANF recipients and service
providers alike in serving recipients living in remote areas.
Under the NEW program, the statute restricts eligibility to tribes and Alaska Native
organizations that were operating JOBS programs in FY 1995. Currently, all 78
eligible tribal grantees are operating NEW programs. Total funding for these programs
is $7.6 million per year with a significant variation in the size of the individual grants
(ranging from just over $5,000 to $1.7 million).
STATE ADMINISTERED TANF PROGRAMS
In the remaining areas of the country, tribal families are served by state TANF programs.
In these areas, tribal communities and tribal members are subject to the same
responsibilities and eligible for the same opportunities that a state elects for its population
at large. As we learn more about the effect these service design choices are having on
tribal families, we certainly will share this information with the Committee. This type of
outcome data is particularly important in light of the unique challenges to self-sufficiency
7
Hex-Dump Conversion
faced by tribal families related to high unemployment and lack of transportation and child
care assistance.
As a start in gathering this critical data, in FY 1997, ACF approved a five-year research
and evaluation project entitled "Welfare to Work: Monitoring the Impact of Welfare
Reform on American Indian Families with Children." The overall purposes of this
longitudinal study are to monitor and document the implementation, and assess the
impact, of welfare reform on American Indian families and reservations in Arizona
resulting from the state and tribal responses to TANF. Extensive demographic,
contextual, socio-economic and case-level data will be compiled from a variety of sources,
including administrative records, tribal documents, interviews and site visits.
One of the preliminary findings of the study is that many tribes while interested in
self-administration of the program, are unsure about the best strategy to follow. They
are interested in learning form the experiences of other tribes in order to examine their
options and make informed choices.
8
Hex-Dump Conversion
On another front, a component of HHS's evaluation of the Department of Labor's
Welfare to Work Grant program will examine what activities and services tribes provide,
and how various tribal programs are coordinated at the localleve!.
CHILD SUPPORT ENFORCEMENT AND CHILD CARE
Child support enforcement is an essential part of welfare reform efforts. The child support
program locates non-custodial parents, establishes paternity, establishes and enforces
support orders, and collects child support payments from those who are legally obligated
to pay. Payment of child support can help a family to leave welfare or combined with
other income, reduce the need for single parent families and their children rely on welfare
in the first place.
Welfare reform enables tribes to operate their own child support enforcement programs
for the first time. PRWORA authorizes direct funding of tribal child support programs,
and with respect to tribes that do not seek this opportunity, includes improvements to
facilitate tribal-state agreements that provide for cooperative delivery of child support
9
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
services in Indian country. This added flexibility provides significant opportunities for
tribes and for Indian children and families: tribal governments can choose to plan and
implement child support programs that meet the unique needs of tribal communities and
improve the delivery of child support services in Indian country.
As I will discuss later in my testimony, we are reviewing the results of an extensive
consultation process which will lead to regulations that implement direct tribal child
support funding. In the meanwhile, although tribes are not yet operating programs
under the broad direct funding approach the law now allows, we are seeing some
promising results from early state-tribal cooperative agreements and tribal demonstration
grants.
_ Cooperative Agreements. Tribes such as the Navajo Nation and the
Sisseton-Wahpeton Sioux Tribe are entering cooperative agreements with their states,
enabling them to carry out tribal child support enforcement and receive funding and
other support through the states' programs. As a result of their cooperative
agreements with the State of New Mexico and Arizona, the Navajo Nation has seen a
big shift in child support collections. The Navajo Nation began child support
enforcement in New Mexico in 1994. Before then, there had been almost no child
support collection on the Navajo Reservation in New Mexico. In 1998, there was
$500,000 in child support collections under the tribe's child support program ill New
Mexico.
10
Hex-Dump Conversion
Tribal Demonstrations. Some tribes are designing child support programs with the
support of our planning and demonstration grants-"Section 1115" grants, Special
Improvement Project grants, and tribal planning grants. Currently, the Chickasaw
Nation, Colville Confederated Tribes, Puyallup Tribe, Lac du Flambeau Band of
Chippewa, Central Council of the Tlingit and Haida Indian Tribes, and the State of
Wisconsin and Menominee Tribe receive this discretionary grant funding. We are
learning from these projects, sharing information, and identifying issues and technical
assistance needs, to help ensure that tribes are able to operate successful child support
programs. Other tribes will benefit from the knowledge gained from these special
grant programs.
The third programmatic area I will focus on today is child care. Child care is' extremely
important to the well-being of our Nation's children and to their parents' ability to work
and maintain employment. and thus a vital supportive service to welfare reform efforts.
The Clinton Administration is dedicated to providing support and resources to ensure
healthy, safe, affordable child care settings that are so desperately needed to help parents
work and help children develop to their full potential and become ready for schoo!.
The Child Care and Development Block Grant (CCDBG) as amended by PRWORA,
assists low-income families and those transitioning off welfare to obtain child care so they
can work or attend training/education. PRWORA amended the CCDBG to bring
together, for the first time, four federal child care subsidy programs thereby allowing
11
Hex-Dump Conversion
states and tribes to design a comprehensive, integrated service delivery system to meet the
needs of low-income families.
Specifically, the law requires a one to two percent tribal set-aside of the aggregate funding
and allows tribes or tribal organizations to use program funds for construction or
renovation purposes as long as it will not result in a decrease in the level of child care
services.
The Secretary has allocated two percent of CCDBG funds for tribes, doubling the
amount of child care funds made available to the tribes since FY 1996. In FY 1999
tribes received $63 million, compared to the $28 million received in FY 1996. In FY
1999, 254 tribal grantees, representing approximately 500 Federally recognized Indian
Tribes and Alaska Native Villages, were awarded child care grants.
Tribes receive CCDBG funding either directly or through consortia arrangements.
According to preliminary 1997 data, 18,755 children were served by tribal childcare
grantees. The majority of these children have working parents (77 percent) or a
parent(s) in training or educational programs (19 percent). The remaining 4 percent
were in protective services. Their income levels vary with 63 percent at or below the
poverty level; 26 percent above poverty but below 150 percent of poverty; 8 percent
above 150 percent; and 3 percent above 200 percent of the poverty level.
12
Hex-Dump Conversion
I would point out that our efforts to increase the supply and availability of child care are
ongomg. The President has unveiled a comprehensive package of child care proposals
that includes significant increases in child care funding to help working families. Beyond
the tax credits and school-age child care funding in the Departments of Treasury and
Education, $10.5 billion in additional funding, over 5 years, is targeted for HHS child
care programs:
_ A five year $7.5 billion increase in the subsidy funding for child care which, when
combined with funds from welfare reform, will increase the number of children
receiving child care assistance by more than 1 million to a total of 2.4 million. The
tribal set-aside provided under law will ensure that this increase in funding serves to
benefit State and tribal child care programs alike.
_ An Early Learning Fund proposed at $3 billion over five years which will, for the
first time, specifically devote funding to communities to enhance the quality and
availability of care, with a focus on promoting school readiness for children through
age five.
I'd like to now turn to ACF's outreach, consultation, and technical assistance efforts to
work with tribes on these historic legislative changes
Outreach, Consultation, and Technical Assistance
13
Hex-Dump Conversion
In increasing the flexibility available to states and Tribes to design their own welfare
reform programs, PWRORA changed the Federal role from one of policy approval to
one that focuses on hands-on support through outreach, technical assistance, and the
dissemination of promising practices, as well as accountability, research, and evaluation.
In this concluding section, I would like to highlight what we have learned and
accomplished so far through consultation, outreach, and technical assistance with our
tribal partners and offer a few notes about the next steps that lie ahead.
Our goals, in keeping with this new role and with the gove'mment-to-govemment
relationship that is central to our work with tribes, are to consult broadly and to provide
information that can assist tribes in making the wide range of choices that they face
about the most effective ways to assist tribal members in becoming self-sufficient. To
help inform these decisions, we have been working with our tribal partners to provide
information about the statute, about policy choices, and about promising practices and
service delivery strategies. We have also worked to bring people together so that they
can share their own expertise, talk about problems and potential solutions, and then
develop strategies.
Outreach and Consultation.
14
Hex-Dump Conversion
In the development of the Tribal TANF Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM),
which was published on July 22,1998, we sought to undertake a broad consultation
strategy prior to drafting the proposed rules. To better inform our policy-making
efforts, we held dozens of conferences, consultations and meetings with representatives of
tribal, state and local governments, as well as soliciting input through a letter. An
extended comment period (through November 20, 1998) was provided on the proposed
rule at the request of commenters and as a result a considerable number of comments
were received from Tribes as well as the National Congress of American Indians. We
expect to publish the final rule this fall.
We continue to look for ways to strengthen and improve our consultation process. As
we work on development of regulations implementing the tribal child support program,
we further intensified our outreach efforts. Six consultations were held in 1998 to obtain
tribal input in developing the regulations in Alaska, Oregon, New Mexico, Minnesota,
Tennessee, and Washington, D.C. Each consultation included an overview of the
national CSE program, followed by tribal input on the tribal program and regulations.
In addition, we established a toll-free "800" number for comments and questions, and we
continue to consult with a resource group of interested and knowledgeable tribal
representatives. The input we have received is extremely valuable in helping to inform
our rulemaking efforts currently underway. We anticipate publication of the regulations
later this year.
15
Hex-Dump Conversion
We are committed to continuing and improving our consultation with tribes as welfare
reform evolves. In addition to our work within ACF, we are coordinating with the
broader tribal consultation strategy conducted by HHS, which has included listening
sessions nationwide as well as the scheduled appointment of a staff specialist in the
Office of the Secretary who will focus exclusively on tribal affairs.
Technical Assistance and Information Dissemination
In addition, we have been involved in providing technical assistance on a number of
fronts:
With respect to TANF, we have sponsored five Promising Practices National
Conferences and there was tribal representation at each. At the Phoenix conference,
a representative from the Center for American Indian Studies presented on the
"Reaching All Families" plenary panel as well as in the "Low Job Skills" workshop,
where tribal issues were discussed.
_ To build on this work, later in April, we are planning a 2-day workshop in Denver to
bring together Region VIII States, Tribes and Tribal Community Colleges. This
workshop is being designed to share information and best practices, strengthen the
16
Hex-Dump Conversion
Tribes' role in welfare reform, improve StatefTribal working relationships and increase
collaboration/networking between and among States, Tribes, and Tribal Community
Colleges.
_ The Administration for Native Americans within ACF has provided resources to
support technical assistance, as well. For example, ANA provided $1.2 million for
five grants to support efforts to develop and disseminate information on TANF,
including convening workshops and meetings with tribes to inform them about
TANF. Additional collaborative work among ACF programs is planned for the
future including comprehensive strategic planning conferences addressing social
services and economic development.
_ The Office of Child Support Enforcement issued briefing packages on the program
, and legislative changes to ensure that tribes could be fully engaged in consultation
meetings. The office also published and sent to all federally recognized tribes a
publication, "Strengthening the Circle: Child Support for Native American
Children." This publication describes the new opportunities for tribal CSE programs
and intergovernmental partnerships to meet the needs of tribal children and families.
17
Hex-Dump Conversion
In Phase II of its contract with the Native American Management Services, Inc.,
OCSE and NAMS are designing technical assistance plans for tribal child support
demonstration grantees. At an initial meeting with grantees held recently, tribal
participants identified problems and areas of need both specific to their tribes as well
as problems and areas of need shared by tribes in general. This information will be
used to develop technical assistance materials for tribes under cooperative agreements
with States and for tribes planning on administering their own child support
programs.
_ With respect to child care, in January 1998, we awarded a three-year contract to
establish and operate a Tribal Child Care Technical Assistance Center (TriTAC).
TriTAC assists tribal grantees in child care capacity building efforts through the
following major activities:a tribal child care home page; a toll-free information and
referral line; a software package to assist with program reporting; a newsletter; and an
annual tribal conference. A database of effective program strategies is also being
developed.
In conjunction with TriTAC, we are currently making plans to hold several training
sessions across the country for tribal child care grantees. The purpose of this special
training is to focus on one or two topic areas that have been identified by tribal
18
Hex-Dump Conversion
grantees, but not covered in depth at the National American Indian/Alaska Native
Child Care Conference, or at ACF regional meetings.
Again, we look forward to building on these technical assistance strategies, and we will
seek to be responsive as welfare reform evolves and the needs of tribes change over time.
CONCLUSION
Our goal in welfare reform is enabling families to move to work and to succeed at work
over the long haul. To accomplish this goal, we are eager to continue working with our
tribal and State partners to support their design of T ANF, child care, and child support
programs that will make the most difference to families. We look forward to building
on the extraordinary creativity and commitment that tribal leaders have already
demonstrated and on the positive first steps that we have already taken together to
share information, to consult, and to provide technical assistance and support in the spirit
of the government-to-government relationship with tribes.We know that in addition to
working internally to coordinate our efforts with the tribes, we also must work with our
19
Hex-Dump Conversion
other Federal partners and the Congress to address the serious economic and social
problems faced by tribes. We are committed to building on these early steps and
working together to see increasing numbers of tribal members improve their lives and
become self-sufficient.
Thank you Mr. Chairman, this concludes my prepared statement. I would be pleased to
respond to any questions you or members of the committee may have.
20
This site parses the emails sent and received by Elena Kagan during her time in the Clinton administration and presents them in a more familiar interface.
You may find that some records are garbled or incomplete, or that conversations are fractured. Please bear with us: the source documents are extremely messy. We're working to improve the quality of the documents hosted here.
Due to the programmatic nature of the tools used to build this site, we recommend checking any research effort against the source files released by the Clinton Library.
You are able to view 26,108 of the 29,281 released emails (89.1%)